Led by Kenya, East Africa emerges as a trade hub

East Africa is emerging as a trade hub to rival sub-Saharan Africa’s two heavyweight states of South Africa and Nigeria, according to analysis by Barclays published on Thursday.

However the UK bank identifies five sleeping giants that present significant new opportunities for foreign companies; Ethiopia, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Mozambique, Tanzania and Ghana.

This quintet which are playing catch-up after significant political and economic upheaval  are increasingly attractive to foreign firms and international investors with an eye on long-term returns from fast-growing markets, Barclays said in its inaugural Africa Trade Index.

Matt Tuck, head of global corporate banking at Barclays, said the five were open to international trade and had rapidly growing populations that are likely to reach 325m in total by 2020, comparable to that of the US.

Moreover, any repeat of the 7.3 per cent compound annual economic growth they have experienced over the past five years would lead to a significant rise in household spending. Most are relatively unreliant on commodity exports by African standards, shielding them from some of the storms currently battering emerging markets.

The core underlying fundamentals are getting better and with more stable government it does represent an opportunity for growth, said Mr Tuck. It’s a much more encouraging outlook than in the past.

Overall, Barclays found South Africa and Nigeria offered the best opportunities for foreign companies, in terms of unmet demand, the absence of major barriers to cross-border trade and their connectivity with other African countries (see the first table).

Barclays Africa Trade Index 2015
Top 10	Score / 100
South Africa	73.3
Nigeria	62.6
Kenya	56.2
Ghana	53.4
Tanzania	52.4
Ethiopia	49.2
Angola	48.7
Cte d’Ivoire	48.5
Sudan	48.4
Senegal	48.3
Source: Barclays

While South Africa is the standout performer, Barclays said Nigeria arguably represented the most exciting long-term opportunity.

However it added that the country suffered from logistical difficulties posed by inadequate infrastructure, which meant many companies had to provide their own power and water supplies.

The bank, which has operated in Africa for more than 150 years and has 1,500 branches across the continent, said Nigeria needed to reduce non-tariff barriers to trade, as well as invest heavily in transport networks and power provision.

Barclays said that east Africa was emerging as a trade hub, with improved border administration helping create a fast-growing regional market.

Barclays Africa Trade Index 2015
Bottom 10	Score / 100
Malawi	38.8
Madagascar	38.8
Rwanda	38.5
Congo	36.5
Gabon	35.2
Lesotho	33.2
Guinea	30.3
Chad	29.9
Burundi	28.2
Gambia	23.4
Source: Barclays

The east African Community introduced a single customs territory last year, earning praise from Erich Kieck, director for capacity building at the World Customs Organisation, for remarkable work simplifying the control of goods moving across the customs union.

Kenya is ranked third in Barclays’ index, with Tanzania and Ethiopia also in the top six. Mr Tuck said Kenya had taken on the role of regional leader, pushing for regional policy in terms of infrastructure and administration and developing strong regional and global air connectivity.

Many countries, particularly in east Africa, have invested in major developments in both infrastructure and soft’ infrastructure such as tariffs and border policies, said Mr Tuck.

He welcomed the development of one-stop border posts, where a single customs check is run jointly by neighbouring countries, rather than each country operating their own station.

East Africa is leading the way in this regard, with seven OSBPs operational or in development in Tanzania and six in Uganda and Kenya, although they are spreading further afield with even Zimbabwe implementing such a system at its Chirundi border post with Zambia.

Developments such as these have helped the dollar value of intra-regional exports expand at a compound annual growth rate of 16 per cent between 2004 and 2013, Barclays said, double the 7.6 per cent CAGR for sub-Saharan exports in total, which hit $460bn in 2014.

Mr Tuck said intra-regional trade still only represented 17 per cent of total trade flows in sub-Saharan Africa, below the levels in regions such as Latin America (20 per cent), North America (32 per cent), Asia (48 per cent) and Europe (66 per cent).

Having said that, bodies such as the African Development Bank have estimated that the true figure is nearer to 40 per cent when informal and unofficial cross-border trade is taken into account.

The report, which was compiled as an aid for UK exporters but has wider ramifications, also pointed to the degree to which Europe has been usurped by the rise of Asia, which accounted for 19 per cent of sub-Saharan Africa’s goods imports in 2004 but 32 per cent by 2013.

Barclays saw some of the best opportunities in the retail sector, with the development of more formal shops, malls and supermarkets allowing customers to trade up, and expanding mobile and internet services creating new avenues for online retailers.

Opportunities abound elsewhere though, with Diageo, the UK drinks group, currently generating 13 per cent of its sales in sub-Saharan Africa, a figure it hopes to raise to 20 per cent.

Follow us on Twitter @em_sqrd

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2016. All rights reserved. You may share using our article tools. Please don't cut articles from FT.com and redistribute by email or post to the web